(solved)Question 2.13 of NCERT Class XI Physics Chapter 2

A physical quantity P is related to four observables a, b, c and d as follows : P= a^3b^2/√c d The percentage errors of measurement in a, b, c and d are 1%, 3%, 4% and 2%, respectively. What is the percentage error in the quantity P ? If the value of P calculated using the above relation turns out to be 3.763, to what value should you round off the result ?

Categories | About Hoven's Blog

Parveen,

Question 2.13
NCERT Class XI Physics

A physical quantity P is related to four observables a, b, c and d as follows : P= a^3b^2/√c d The percentage errors of measurement in a, b, c and d are 1%, 3%, 4% and 2%, respectively. What is the percentage error in the quantity P ? If the value of P calculated using the above relation turns out to be 3.763, to what value should you round off the result ?

Solution

The given expression is a multiply and divide type of expression.

REMEMBER: The relative error of each quantity gets multiplied by the power and relative errors of multiplicands and dividends get added.

$ \begin{aligned} &\therefore \text{\% error in P} = \\ &3\Delta a/a + 2\Delta b/b + \frac12\Delta c/c + \Delta d/d\\ &= 3 \times 1\% + 2 \times 3\% + \frac12 \times 4\%+ 2\%\\ &= 13\%\:\underline{Ans}\\\\ &\underline{\underline{\text{second part now. . . }}}\\ &\text{given }P = 3.763 \\ &\therefore \Delta P = 13\% \text{ of } 3.763 = 0.490 \\ &\text{uncertainty at tenths place}\\ &\text{so round to tenths place}\\ &= 3.8\:\underline{Ans}\\\\ \end{aligned} $

Video Explanation

Please watch this youtube video for a quick explanation of the solution:

Physical Concept
(for the Advanced Student)

P is a multiply-divide type of expression in quantities "a", "b", "c" and "d" raised to powers. The relative errors in a (1%), b(2%), c(3%) and d(4%) will multiply according as their respective powers, and then overall error will be obtained by adding all such errors.

The overall error in P is calculated [see above] to 13%.

The second part says that calculated value of P is 3.763. Hence, the overall error in P is 13% of 3.763 = 0.490. We can see that the error starts in the tenth place. So the value of P, i.e., 3.763 will have an uncertainty in its tenth place. Therefore, the result must be rounded to the tenths place to get 3.8 as the answer.

Personally I am of the opinion that the second part of the question is a bit ambiguous for the level of a class XI student. The range of P is 3.763 +/- 0.490, that comes to 3.273 to 4.253 which shows that the digit 3 itself is un-certain. This makes it difficult for a class XI student to understand.
Creative Commons License
This Blog Post/Article "(solved)Question 2.13 of NCERT Class XI Physics Chapter 2" by Parveen is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.